5 Reasons Why The Model Alliance is Being a Cry Baby

I don’t want to diss the Model Alliance, because I do think modelling is a tough job. A career often starts in the teens, and the job is based 99% on your looks, which no doubt causes self-image issues for a lot of the girls. The Model Alliance recently released a survey (who only had 85 respondents) that resulted a few interesting (and sad) findings. But hey, how many legal jobs can you earn $10,000 a day a the age of 18? Not many. Here’s some of the findings, and my comments.

models, fashion lists, fashion industry, model alliance, working conditions

Model Hanna E shot by Saga Wendotte.

1. Models need to learn that their job is to be clothes horses, and that means their body is used to hang clothes. That also means that while they are changing clothes, people might see the body underneath. “60.5% of models say their lack of privacy while changing clothes at work is a concern.” Well, I am sorry, but if you are a model, you’ve got to be prepared to walk around in nothing but a skimpy thong and be ok with that. It is part of the job. Get over it.

models, fashion lists, fashion industry, model alliance, working conditions

Model Hannah Saul shot by Tommy Clarke.

2. The fashion industry is not known for its clean living mantra, and models need to understand that. “50.6% of models have been exposed to cocaine.” I’d like to know the percentages of cocaine exposure for fashion designers and journalists, not to mention everyone else involved in the industry. Sadly, there are a lot of fashion people who use drugs and yeah, it sucks being a 13 year old and being exposed to cocaine, but unfortunately, it is part of the industry. If you don’t like it, get a paper route.

3. The pressure to be thin is not exclusive to models. “48.7% fast, do ‘cleanses,’ or otherwise restrict their food intake over short periods to lose weight.” I’d be interested to know how many NORMAL women to the above. I am guessing it is WAY more than 48.7%. Yes, there is a pressure to be thin as a model. But that’s the job description. Sorry, deal with it.

models, fashion lists, fashion industry, model alliance, working conditions

Model Martyna Budya shot by Francesco Brigida.

4. It is not the industry’s job to make sure the models are properly chaperoned. “28% of under 18 models never have parents or guardians go with them to castings and jobs.” Given that a lot of them travel far from their hometown, this statistic is not surprising. Personally, if I had a 15 year old daughter who stood a chance at making it as a model, I would accompany her to everything. EVERYTHING. But some parents can’t do that. The industry isn’t to blame, and to be honest, neither are the agencies. If you let your young daughter fly off to a big city and start a model career, you had better make sure she is taken care of, and if not, you had better hope to hell she has a good head on her shoulders.

models, fashion lists, fashion industry, model alliance, working conditions

Model Brittany Hollis shot by Jeff Tse.

5. Anxiety and depression are suffered by young women universally. Or a least, in the Western world. “68.3% of models suffer from anxiety and/or depression.” I am pretty sure this statistic matches what most 13-25 year old women feel, and so this shouldn’t come as a surprise. In fact, I am pretty sure that most of the world suffers from anxiety occasionally. This is not a feeling exclusive to models, it is the way most of us feel, some of the time.

While I think that someone needs to advocate for the rights of these girls, I also think they need to look at the big picture. Modelling is tough, but if you are successful, you can make money. A LOT of money. And in a very short time. Like most high earning jobs, the working conditions aren’t exactly ideal, but you get compensated. That might mean seeing people do cocaine in the bathrooms, feeling anxiety before a big catwalk show, having to diet, and having to change in front of a bunch of people, but these are known to be part of the modelling world. If you don’t like it, then don’t model.

Images from Fashion Gone Rogue and statistics from this Fashionista article.

This entry was posted in Fashion Lists, The Fashion Industry and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.
  • jasper

    exactly.

  • Rachel

    I’m not sure I understand your statements. They make it seem that you are ok with girls under the age of 18 to be representing the images of the perfect women. Doesn’t it matter to you these children are working in a totally unregulated industry? Are you saying it is their own problem? What about the pressure and the lies imposed on the girls and their families? Have you thought of it? It’s easy to stand from the side and criticise people who are standing up for themselves and others, yet have you experience how it is to be a model yourself or someone very close to you? I believe every worker in the world should work under norms and regulations, but since this is difficult in most industries let’s at least stop having minors in it! Plus do you realised that for 1 girls that might get a 10 000$ job for a day there are thousands getting into debts modelling?! And yes, women who are not models might suffer deppression, eating disorders and be exposed to cocaine, yet models are on their own away from their family with no support aside from agents who are trying to make money out of them… You should check out this documentary : http://www.girlmodelthemovie.com

  • Anonymous

    I haven’t commented on my opinion about whether I think it is ok for under 18′s to represent “perfect women” in the media, but that is a story for a whole other day. And until the majority of society sees beauty in a size 10 40-year old, we are probably going to continue to see emaciated 15 year olds on catwalks.

    I am not criticizing the Model Alliance for standing up for themselves, but I am trying to draw attention to the fact that models need to realize what they are getting into when they decide to embark on that career path. Most potentially high earning jobs have major risks involved, modeling is no different. I DO feel sorry for the girls who are young and on their own away from their family, but its not like they have no idea what they are getting into. Just like I wouldn’t allow a 15 year old child of mine travel around Europe with friends, I also wouldn’t allow them to embark on a high stress, emotional, and potentially dangerous career path like modeling.

    I saw what happened behind the scenes to the young models when I worked in Paris, and I didn’t see any serious instances of them being mistreated (I know there are exceptions) but I did see in general that it is tiring, emotionally draining, and NOT the type of job I would want a teenager doing. And the industry is not “totally unregulated.” This isn’t prostitution, this is mostly large companies with a basic level of ethics. But when you throw vulnerable teenagers into a fast-paced, competitive, judgmental industry, there are bound to be casualties. The solution, in my opinion, is not protection, it is prevention. Don’t let teenagers work in this industry. If they do decide to, then it should be at their own risk.

  • Rachel

    “The industry is not “totally unregulated”"?  I am very curious to know where and which regulation are official in the fashion industry for models.

    Modelling is NOT a high earning job, except in a few very rare cases…

    I am very glad your experience as a model were safe, but I think the
    girls that have never been mistreated are the exceptions in the
    industry!

    Most of the time teenage girls that start modelling have no idea what goes on in the industry, there hasn’t been many models yet that have spoken out on issues going on in the industry, so the Model Alliance are an essential voice.

    Is it society seeing prepubescent girls as beauty on their own or is it the fashion industry that has imposed this image on society? Why does the fashion industry doesn’t want to only use adults to represent adults?

  • Anonymous

     I was not a model, but I worked as a designer and therefore with models on a frequent basis. Most big companies do not have specific regulation for models, but they are large companies that cannot get away with treating their employees (permanent or contract) like crap. Paris and New York is not the Wild West.

    Like you said, most teenage girls have no idea what goes on. Isn’t it their, or their parents’, responsibility to find this out before they embark on that career path? I agree the Model Alliance is an essential voice, but I also think that models need to understand what the industry is about. Its not like the information is hard to find these days, everything is on the internet. There is no excuse for not having at least a faint idea of the going ons.

    As for the use of teenage models with regards to society’s idea of beauty, that, as I said, is another argument completely.

  • Rachel

    The use of teenage models might seem like another argument, yet the abuses in the fashion industry will keep happening if children keeps working in it representing adults.
    Is it justifiable to say there are bad practices in the fashion industry, and that it’s for the models to know before they embark in their career…and they just have to deal with it? I think wherever basic human rights are not respected it should be denunciated, not accepted as normal.
    Unfortuantly I think many large companies are getting away with treating employees (permanent or on contract) like crap… but which girl will come up to speak about it… they will scare her off to or offer money to buy silence…